Pull-Ups vs Diapers: Differences (What’s Better?)

Updated On:

by Basana Saha

As an Amazon Affiliate KidsCareIdeas earn from every qualifying purchases linked to Amazon.com and its affiliates.

Most parents have to decide what to use when it’s time for Potty training.

Some go for pull-ups, while others prefer diapers. Both have their Pros and Cons, but which one is better?

Let’s look at the pros and cons of both and let you decide.

Pull-ups and diapers are both used to absorb the waste from infants. But are diapers a better option?

This blog will compare Pull-Ups vs Diapers and highlight the differences and hence would help you know which is better.

Pull-Ups vs Diapers

Let’s get started!

Pull-Ups vs Diapers

Use CasesUse During Day and Night (with Overnight Pull-Ups)Use during day and night
Aid Potty trainingYesNo

What are Pull-Ups?

Pull-ups are a type of absorbent undergarment, usually worn by children when they are toilet-training or are unable to use the toilet independently. 

Pull-ups are very similar to diapers, with the main difference being that pull-ups are much easier for children to use on their own.

Pull-ups are designed to fit loosely and can be pulled up and down, making them easier to remove and put back on.

How do pull-ups work?

Well, pull-ups are essentially underwear. They have the same opening and closing system as regular undergarments but with a little more protection.

The cloth of the underwear is made with a special waterproof material that prevents the absorption of liquids.

What are diapers?

Diapers are soft, absorbent items worn by infants and toddlers to prevent them from urinating and defecating on themselves.

Diapers are made of an outer waterproof shell and an inner layer of soft material.

Most modern diapers have a fastening system to keep them closed and help stop liquid leakage. 

There are two main types of diapers: 

  • Cloth diapers: Cloth diapers are reusable and can be washed and dried by the user. There are several types of Cloth diapers available in the market from which you can choose.
  • Disposable diapers: Disposable diapers are not reusable and are thrown away when dirty. However, some modern versions of disposable diapers are made to be flushed down the toilet or composted.

You may also like to read about:

How do diapers work?

A diaper is a wrap placed around the waist of a baby to prevent the baby from making a mess.

Diapers are made of a synthetic or natural absorbent material shaped and laid out for the baby’s bottom. And don’t forget about the adhesive tabs that hold the diapers together.

They are used to ensure that the diaper is secure for the baby. The combination of these three things is what makes a diaper work. 

There are also plastic linings that hold the padding together. Depending on the baby’s age, different diapers are available.

A diaper is meant to hold the fecal matter until it is removed. You can dispose of the diaper in a trash can or a diaper pail.

What is the difference between diapers and pull-ups?

Diapers and pull-ups are often confused with each other. Although both protect children from their urine, they don’t serve the same purpose and are designed differently.

The diaper is a protective material that you wrap around your child’s waist to prevent the urine from reaching their clothes. 

On the other hand, pull-ups are fastened around your child’s waist in a similar way to underwear and can be taken off and put on by the kids themselves.

Diapers are adjustable, depending on the child’s weight.

However, pull-ups are not adjustable but come in different sizes.

Overnight pull-ups vs diapers

Overnight pull-ups are a great alternative to sleeping with a diaper at night. While they’re a little easier to use, they’re also cheaper, more comfortable, and will last a long time.

These pull-ups are worn at night while the child sleeps, and they keep the child feeling dry and comfortable.

While these pull-ups are very similar to diapers, they do have some key differences. 

Overnight pull-ups are a must for most parents who have to deal with bed-wetting!

For example, pull-ups are slightly more absorbent than diapers, which means they can hold more than diapers.

Pull-ups are also a little more comfortable than diapers, and they’re a lot easier to put on than diapers.

Do pull-ups work as well as diapers? Are they absorbent?

Although both are made of several absorbent materials, Some parents claim that diapers are more reliable and less prone to leaking than pull-ups. 

Parents have the choice to choose between either of these products depending on their circumstances.

Infants who cannot handle themselves are better off with diapers, while potty-training toddlers can switch to pull-ups.

Pros and cons of Diapers


  • They are adjustable
  • They are very absorbent.
  • You don’t have to worry about accidents.
  • More readily available (in local stores)


  • Do not aid potty training.
  • May make standing up more challenging.
  • Do not encourage the kid’s independence.

Pros and cons of Pull-Ups


  • Encourages the toddler to be independent
  • Aid potty training for youngsters
  • Come in various sizes and protection levels according to need
  • Available in gender-customized colors


  • Not as absorbent as diapers
  • You may still have to change, especially if worn at night
  • Costlier than diapers

Are pull-ups bad for potty training?

Pull-ups are designed to help parents with potty training. Since they are like training pants, they allow the child to wear them without getting into an accident.

However, their similarity to diapers may extend the potty training period for some toddlers.

Can you potty train with diapers?

Ideally, a kid cannot potty train with diapers on.

Still, you can potty train during the day, but put the kid in diapers overnight.

The idea is that the child can potty train only when not in diapers, although they haven’t outgrown the nappy.

Where can you purchase Pull-Ups or Diapers?

You can check Pull Ups or Diapers from Amazon.

Here are some awesome Pull Up Options:

Here are some Awesome Diaper Options for your baby:


Let’s conclude the post!

Pull-ups and diapers are both great for kids, but each has its benefits and drawbacks.

After reading, you should be able to make a well-informed decision about your child’s preference for Pull-Ups vs Diapers.

Ultimately, the choice comes down to your child and what they are most comfortable with.

I hope you enjoyed reading this comparison.

Was this Post helpful?

Thanks for your feedback!

Analyzed By Basana Saha

Basana Saha has expertise working for more than 25 years as a beautician. She has expertise in choosing the right accessories and gears for your baby. Being a mom she knows the problems new moms face. She would like to help with Parenting to new moms with her expertise in raising a child. Learn More About Basana Saha.